2023 Criminal Defense Results
All dispositions may be verified by contacting the clerk of the county court.
Below are the results of every criminal case resolved by plea or dismissal in 2023.
For the results of every criminal case resolved by jury trial, please visit the jury verdicts results page.
State of Florida v. T.A.M.; 48-2023-CF-6142-AO
Date Closed: |
December 29, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Jenifer Harris |
Charge(s): |
- Child Abuse (F3)
- Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. C.M.D.; 48-2023-CT-7199-AO
Date Closed: |
December 15, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Carly Wish |
Charge(s): |
- Leaving Scene of Crash (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Civil Infraction: WH and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. E.A.H.; 59-2023-CF-1818-A
Date Closed: |
November 9, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable Melanie Chase |
Charge(s): |
- Grand Theft of Controlled Substance (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- WH, 18 months of probation, 50 community service hours, substance abuse treatment, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. E.J.A.; 48-2022-CF-14289-AO
Date Closed: |
November 3, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Thomas Sawaya |
Charge(s): |
- VOP: Possession of Firearm by a Delinquent (F2)
|
Disposition: |
- WH, probation reinstated, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.X.T.; 48-2023-MO-1452-AO
Date Closed: |
November 1, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Martha Adams |
Charge(s): |
- Disorderly Conduct (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. N.I.T.; 48-2023-CF-4022-AO
Date Closed: |
November 1, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Wayne Wooten |
Charge(s): |
- Possession of Cocaine (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- AG, time served, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. T.P.; 48-2017-CF-3599-AO
State of Florida v. T.P.; 48-2017-CF-9806-AO
Date Closed: |
October 31, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Patricia Strowbridge |
Charge(s): |
- Aggravated Stalking after Injunction (F3)
- Aggravated Stalking after Injunction (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Violation of Injunction (M1): WH, 12 months of probation, Batterers Intervention Program, 50 community service hours, and court costs.
- Pled to Violation of Injunction (M1): WH, 12 months of consecutive probation, 50 community service hours, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. S.R.C.; 05-2023-CT-44002-A
Date Closed: |
October 31, 2023 |
County: |
Brevard |
Judge: |
The Honorable Michelle Baker |
Charge(s): |
- DUI (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Reckless Driving: WH, 9 months of probation, DUI school and treatment, 50 community service hours, $400 donation, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.C.R.; 48-2023-CT-5915-AO
Date Closed: |
October 27, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Carly Wish |
Charge(s): |
- Leaving Scene of Crash (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Civil Infraction: WH and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. Q.J.R.; 48-2023-CF-6142-AO
Date Closed: |
October 20, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Wayne Wooten |
Charge(s): |
- Child Abuse (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.M.W.; 48-2023-CF-7520-AO
Date Closed: |
October 20, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Jenifer Harris |
Charge(s): |
- Criminal Mischief (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. A.S.; 59-2022-CT-1992-A
Date Closed: |
October 17, 2023 |
County: |
Volusia |
Charge(s): |
- DUI (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Reckless Driving: WH, 9 months of probation, DUI school and treatment, 75 community service hours, $1,400 in fines court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.M.H.; 48-2023-MM-651-AW
Date Closed: |
October 12, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.A.C.; 35-2023-CF-1349-A
Date Closed: |
October 9, 2023 |
County: |
Lake |
Judge: |
The Honorable Heidi Davis |
Charge(s): |
- Child Neglect (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.M.B.; 64-2023-MM-104219-ADL
Date Closed: |
October 3, 2023 |
County: |
Volusia |
Judge: |
The Honorable Belle Schumann |
Charge(s): |
- Leaving Scene of Crash (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Careless Driving: WH and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. T.N.S.; 48-2023-MM-5473-AO
Date Closed: |
October 2, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Elizabeth Starr |
Charge(s): |
- Unlawful Use of a Badge (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. E.M.A.; 48-2023-MM-6079-AO
Date Closed: |
September 22, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Doug Walker |
Charge(s): |
- Petit Theft (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. P.J.M..; 49-2023-CT-1284-A
Date Closed: |
September 18, 2023 |
County: |
Lake |
Judge: |
The Honorable Emily Curington |
Charge(s): |
- DUI with Property Damage (M1)
- Leaving Scene of Crash (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- AG, 12 months of probation, DUI school and treatment, 50 community service hours, $500 fine, and court costs.
- AG and time served.
|
State of Florida v. J.L.C.; 59-2022-CF-2914-A
Date Closed: |
September 11, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable Melissa Souto |
Charge(s): |
- Grand Theft Third Degree (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.L.; 48-2023-MM-5733-AO
Date Closed: |
September 10, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. A.I.T.; 48-2021-CF-12597-AO
Date Closed: |
August 23, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Kevin B. Weiss |
Charge(s): |
- VOP: Armed Trespass of a Structure (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Probation reinstated.
|
State of Florida v. B.M.M.; 48-2023-MM-5273-AO
Date Closed: |
August 15, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. H.A.G.; 48-2023-MM-4720-AW
Date Closed: |
July 28, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.M.Z.; 48-2022-MM-6336-AO
Date Closed: |
July 25, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Doug Walker |
Charge(s): |
- Disorderly Intoxication (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. N.V.H.; 48-2023-CT-4372-AO
Date Closed: |
July 24, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Steve Jewett |
Charge(s): |
- Leaving Child Unattended in a Vehicle (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Amended to Civil Infraction: WH, $75 fine, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. D.C.S.; 59-2023-MM-2085-A
Date Closed: |
July 14, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable James DeKleva |
Charge(s): |
- Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. D.C.S.; 59-2023-CF-1393-A
Date Closed: |
June 30, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable Donna Goerner |
Charge(s): |
- Lewd or Lascivius Touching (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. C.M.H.; 48-2023-MM-3660-AO
Date Closed: |
June 26, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. D.T.M.; 59-2022-MM-4113-A
Date Closed: |
June 19, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable James DeKleva |
Charge(s): |
- Petit Theft (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. P.J.M..; 49-2023-CT-1284-A
Date Closed: |
June 9, 2023 |
County: |
Osceola |
Judge: |
The Honorable Hal Epperson |
Charge(s): |
- DUI (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- AG, 12 months of probation, DUI school and treatment, 50 community service hours, $500 fine, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. P.F.S.; 18-2023-CF-169-A
State of Florida v. P.F.S.; 18-2023-CF-220-A
Date Closed: |
June 5, 2023 |
County: |
Flagler |
Judge: |
The Honorable Terence Perkins |
Charge(s): |
- Aggravated Fleeing and Eluding (F2)
- Leaving the Scene of Accident (M2)
- Fleeing and Eluding (F3)
- Reckless Driving (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- AG, 20 months prison, 1 year driver license suspension, and court costs.
- AG and time served.
- AG, concurrent 20 months prison, 1 year driver license suspension, and court costs.
- AG and time served.
|
State of Florida v. J.M.S.; 59-2023-CF-708-A
State of Florida v. J.M.S.; 59-2023-MM-1391-A
Date Closed: |
May 24, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable James DeKleva |
Charge(s): |
- Aggravated Battery on Pregnant Person (F2)
- Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
- WH and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.K.H.; 48-2023-MM-3124-AO
Date Closed: |
May 10, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. S.V.W.; 59-2023-MM-1505-A
Date Closed: |
May 9, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable Wayne Culver |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.H.; 59-2021-MM-1180-A
Date Closed: |
May 8, 2023 |
County: |
Seminole |
Judge: |
The Honorable Wayne Culver |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.L.S.; 48-2023-CF-90-AO
Date Closed: |
May 8, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Jenifer Harris |
Charge(s): |
- Fleeing and Eluding (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- AG, 12 months of probation, 50 community service hours, 1 year driver license suspension, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.M.; 48-2022-CT-3817-AO
Date Closed: |
April 25, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Faye Allen |
Charge(s): |
- DUI (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. R.G.; 49-2023-MM-189-A
Date Closed: |
April 24, 2023 |
County: |
Osceola |
Judge: |
The Honorable Gabrielle Sanders |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. G.D.A.; 48-2022-CF-10758-AO
Date Closed: |
April 18, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Tarlika Nunez-Navarro |
Charge(s): |
- First Degree Arson (F1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. O.A.G.; 60-2023-CT-789-AM
Date Closed: |
April 11, 2023 |
County: |
Sumter |
Judge: |
The Honorable Paul Militello |
Charge(s): |
- Driving While License Suspended (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. D.C.W.; 35-2022-MM-5553-A
Date Closed: |
April 4, 2023 |
County: |
Lake |
Judge: |
The Honorable Sarah Jones |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. L.D.J.; 64-2022-CF-101549-ADL
Date Closed: |
February 28, 2023 |
County: |
Volusia |
Judge: |
The Honorable Randell Rowe |
Charge(s): |
- Written Threats to Kill (F2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Assault on Elderly Person (M1): WH, 12 months probation, mental health treatment, and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.D.R.; 48-2023-MM-726-AO
Date Closed: |
February 15, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Adam McGinnis |
Charge(s): |
- Domestic Violence Battery (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. A.G.C.; 48-2022-CT-6647-AO
Date Closed: |
February 15, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Carly Wish |
Charge(s): |
- Leaving Scene of an Accident (M2)
|
Disposition: |
- Pled to Civil Infraction of Failure to Exchange Insurance Information: WH and court costs.
|
State of Florida v. J.F.C.; 48-2023-CT-42-AW
Date Closed: |
February 7, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Elizabeth Starr |
Charge(s): |
- Racing (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. D.J.R.; 48-2022-CF-8187-AO
Date Closed: |
February 3, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Diego Madrigal |
Charge(s): |
- Written Threats to Kill (F2)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. N.D.B.; 49-2022-MM-1185-A
Date Closed: |
February 2, 2023 |
County: |
Osceola |
Judge: |
The Honorable Gabrielle Sanders |
Charge(s): |
- Solicitation of Prostitution (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. J.D.D.; 64-2022-CF-304323-ADB
Date Closed: |
January 25, 2023 |
County: |
Volusia |
Judge: |
The Honorable Raul Zambrano |
Charge(s): |
- Felony Battery (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. D.J.R.; 48-2022-CF-9105-AO
Date Closed: |
January 11, 2023 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Diego Madrigal |
Charge(s): |
- Child Neglect (F3)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
State of Florida v. R.M.C.; 48-2022-MM-311-AE
Date Closed: |
December 27, 2022 |
County: |
Orange |
Judge: |
The Honorable Faye Allen |
Charge(s): |
- Unlawful Open House Party (M1)
|
Disposition: |
- Dismissed
|
Previous Years' Results
2024 | 2023 | 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012 | 2011 | 2010 | 2009 | 2008
Florida Bar Rules Regarding Past Results
The Florida Bar governs the dissemination of past results to protect potential clients from obtaining an unjustified expectation about the results a lawyer can achieve. As a result, all information concerning past results must be factually verifiable and not misleading, so please understand:
- The information has not been reviewed or approved by The Florida Bar.
- The facts and circumstances of your case may differ from the cases for which results are provided.
- The results of all cases handled by criminal lawyer Richard Hornsby are not provided.
- The results are not necessarily representative of results obtained by criminal lawyer Richard Hornsby or of the experience of other clients.
- Every case is different, and each client's case must be evaluated and handled on its own merits.
References